WTF Happened to American History X?
Powerful, polarizing, and undeniably provocative, few movies made in the 1990s have had as lasting an impact as Tony Kaye’s American History X. In a cinematic decade bookended by such masterworks as Scorsese’s Goodfellas and Kubrick’s Eyes Wide Shut, American History X towers neck-and-neck with Spielberg’s Schindler’s List as an unforgettable experience rebuking the hateful ideology of the Third Reich and its neo-Nazi offspring. With such prejudicial and racist sentiments sadly proliferating in the popular rise of social media, the cautionary tale of disaffected youth channeling their hate-fueled anger in all the wrong places has become even more important in 2025.
A heartrending crime drama that pulls no punches with its wind-knocking sociopolitical message, American History X is loosely based on screenwriter David McKenna’s childhood and, independently, the lives of white supremacists Frank Meeink and Tom Metzger. Yet, for as powerful and prescient as the film was almost 30 years ago, it’s surprising to learn that Tony Kaye remains deeply unhappy with the version that New Line Cinema released in 1998. Kaye’s dissatisfaction stems from several editorial changes led by star Edward Norton, whose magnificent performance remains among the best of his career. Between the ugly directorial dispute, the story inspiration, the casting process, the lengthy film shoot, and the much different alternate ending, it’s only right to find out what the f*ck happened to American History X!
In a remarkable feat for a first-time screenwriter, David McKenna sold the script for American History X to New Line Cinema when he was 26 years old. McKenna, who grew up in a lawless punk rock subculture in San Diego, was inspired to write the story based on his firsthand experience with hate-mongering bigotry. The idea was to communicate that nobody is born with racist ideologies, but that each individual is a product of their environment and develops their beliefs accordingly. Rather than speaking for McKenna on such a sensitive subject, consider the quote he gave when promoting the film:
“I saw a lot of bigotry growing up, and it made me think about writing something about the world of hate-mongers. The point I tried to make in the script is that a person is not born a racist. It is learned through the environment and the people that surround you. The question that intrigued me is: why do people hate, and how does one go about changing that? My premise was that hate starts in the family.”
With the sobering theme in mind, McKenna sought to capture the utmost realism among the characters, deliberately interviewing and studying the behavior of real-life skinheads while writing the script. Producer John Morrissey read the script and was struck by the vivid character development and rich dialogue. Morrissey passed the screenplay to Mike De Luca, the head of production at New Line Cinema at the time, who was also impressed by the searing character study of Derek Vinyard, a woefully misguided young man from a supposedly good home who becomes indoctrinated by white supremacist beliefs before reforming his life. Despite the alarming material, De Luca deserves credit for seeing the artistic potential and greenlighting American History X with little hesitation.
Tony Kaye hired to direct
With New Line’s blessing, Dennis Hopper was the first director approached for the movie in 1996. Once Hopper turned down the offer due to the studio’s refusal to meet his $1 million fee, Larry Clark was asked to direct the film on the strength of his gritty street drama Kids. While Clark was unavailable due to a scheduling snafu, he ended up working with David McKenna on the underrated 2001 thriller Bully.
Once Hopper and Clark declined to direct, De Luca circled back to his original choice, British music video director Tony Kaye. Just as American History X marked McKenna’s first screenplay, the movie was also Kaye’s debut feature as a director. While it’s unclear what De Luca saw in Kaye to think he was the right person to helm American History X, Kaye notably directed the unforgettable music video for Soul Asylum’s “Runaway Train” in 1993. Once hired to direct, Kaye signed his contract in the presence of a rabbi, which he thought would bless the film and lead to success.
When it came time to cast the lead role of Derek Vinyard, Joaquin Phoenix was the first actor offered the role. However, Phoenix found the material too upsetting and declined the part. Kaye held subsequent casting calls that proved futile, and he nearly gave up when he couldn’t find the right actor for the role. Thankfully, casting director Valerie McCaffrey suggested Edward Norton to portray Derek Vinyard, fresh off his incredible, Oscar-nominated debut in Primal Fear. Believe it or not, Kaye immediately balked at the idea, believing that Norton lacked the gravitas to play the role, but eventually gave in. Meanwhile, Norton was quite hesitant to take the role until Francis Ford Coppola convinced him it was a good idea.
Once cast, Norton’s passion for the project was so infectious that he took a 50% pay cut to star in the film, reducing his $1 million fee in half. He also turned down a starring role in Saving Private Ryan to portray Derek Vinyard in American History X. Perhaps validating his decision to play such a risky role, Norton earned an Academy Award nomination alongside Tom Hanks in 1999. However, both lost out to Roberto Benigni for Life is Beautiful.
As for Edward Furlong’s casting as Derek’s younger brother, Danny Vinyard, it was also McCaffrey’s idea. Before Stacy Keach was brilliantly cast as Cameron Alexander, Marlon Brando was considered for the role. Alexander is loosely based on Tom Metzger, the real-life leader of the White Aryan Resistance, a despicable white supremacist group based in Southern California. Similarly, Derek Vinyard is loosely inspired by Frank Meeink, a reformed white supremacist skinhead who left the racist organization to speak out against it publicly. To prepare for the part, Norton gained 25 to 30 pounds of muscle by adhering to a strict diet and gym regimen. Norton and Furlong shaved their heads before filming commenced.
Not for nothing, but for such unpleasant material, it is a bit curious that Boy Meets World co-stars Ethan Suplee and William Russ were cast to play Seth Ryan and Dennis Vinyard, narrow-minded racists with unfettered hate in their hearts. But anyway…
Tagged with an estimated $20 million budget, principal photography on American History X began on March 17, 1997, and wrapped on May 21. The two-month film shoot took place in and around Los Angeles, primarily in Venice Beach, where the story is set. The high school scenes were filmed at Venice High School, the same exterior of which was used to film Rydell High in the hit musical Grease. In addition to directing the film, Kaye served as the cinematographer and camera operator, often silently stalking around the set to find the most effective camera angles and setups. Despite being an unconventional choice to helm a distinctly American movie, the British Kaye fostered a casual, comfortable set that made the actors as relaxed as possible, considering the difficult material. Kaye encouraged people to visit the set, including Norton’s then-girlfriend Courtney Love, British historian John Richardson, and others.
Yet, despite creating a welcoming environment and eliciting terrific performances, both Furlong and Suplee had trouble playing such hate-fueled neo-Nazis. For instance, the “white power” tattoo on Seth’s arm remained intact between takes. When he went to the store one day on a break from filming, Suplee completely forgot the tattoo was still on his arm and was confronted by an irate stranger who thought it was real.
Meanwhile, as a bit of an odd bird to say the least, Kaye would routinely arrive at work each day in a chauffeured Lincoln Town Car with the license plate JEWISH. Kaye also showed up each day with four cellular phones and a fax machine. He even passed out matzah to the cast and crew during Passover, leaning into his Jewish ethnicity while making the film. While these antics were fairly genial, Kaye’s quirky personality would become far more problematic during post-production.
Controversial violence
Now, one of the most indelible moments in the movie comes around the 54-minute mark, when Derek brutally and fatally curb-stomps one of the Crips gang members outside of his house. For as savagely violent as that image remains, Norton said that when he applied force to the rubber dummy while filming the scene, the doll’s head popped off and rolled down the street, causing everyone to erupt with laughter. Speaking of the notorious curb-stomping scene, in an early draft of the story, Cameron was the one who experienced such a grisly demise at the hands of a gang member. The draft also had Seth getting shot and dying at the end of the movie before it was changed to him and Cameron being physically battered.
After the infamous curb-stomping, Derek is given a three-year prison sentence for voluntary manslaughter. In jail, Derek meets Lamont, played by Guy Torry. The reason that Derek and Lamont’s basketball debate at the 122-minute mark sounds so authentic is that most of the lines were improvised on the spot by Norton and Torry. The conversation developed naturally out of Norton’s real-life love of the Boston Celtics and Torry’s true fandom of the Los Angeles Lakers.
Yet, as wonderful as their laundry room debate is in prison, fully enriching each other’s characters, Tony Kaye was not happy with the diversions from the script and became frustrated with his actors. Kaye was most aggravated by Norton and Furlong, who would constantly alter the script during the filming process. Kaye became so distraught that he wanted to quit the production, claiming that the constant fiddling with the script drastically departed from his original vision and that he felt no reason to continue. He was also reportedly not a fan of the towering performance Norton gave and still considers the movie unfinished to this day. Unfortunately, Kaye’s misgivings would become more vocal and complicated during the editing phase.
Before delving into the post-production drama, it’s worth telling fans that the diner that Derek and Danny visit at the end of the movie is Johnie’s Coffee Shop on Wilshire and Fairfax. It’s the same café where Miracle Mile was filmed and where Walter and The Dude hang out in The Big Lebowski, which was released roughly eight months before American History X. The café was closed for business in 2000 and is exclusively used for movie and TV productions. In 2016, the café was renamed Bernie’s Coffee Shop after Senator Bernie Sanders, who, ironically, is a member of the Jewish faith.
As for the final lines recited from Danny’s American History X term paper, they are lifted directly from Abraham Lincoln’s first inaugural address to the Union in 1861. While this is easy enough to miss, it perhaps suggests that Danny had a profound change of heart due to Derek’s reformed influence and was on a path toward reconciliation and redemption before his shocking death.
A post-production nightmare
Once American History X completed filming in May 1997, the film languished in editorial hell for the next 18 months. Tony Kaye had submitted his ideal version of the film, which ran for 95 minutes and was delivered on time and without additional budgetary costs. Despite the 95-minute version playing well to test audiences, New Line felt the story was too slight and insisted on further edits and adding more footage to the movie. This deeply enraged Kaye so much that he went ballistic against the studio, declaring that, despite being an unproven first-time filmmaker, he deserved the same creative autonomy and iron-clad final cut control that the great Stanley Kubrick had. He also accused Norton of taking editorial control to prolong his screen time.
Of course, New Line did not meet such lofty and ludicrous demands. Instead, Norton tried to smooth things over by joining the editing process with Kaye, which only exacerbated the problem further. Kaye and Norton were at such odds on how the movie should play that at one point, Kaye bashed a wall out of frustration and required stitches on his hand. One of the biggest points of contention was the film’s final shot. Kaye’s original cut featured an ending in which Derek, fully enraged after Danny’s murder, is shown shaving his head in a bathroom mirror. The implication being that Derek will perpetuate the cycle of racist, violent hatred he worked so hard to get rid of and reform to be a better role model for Danny. Norton profoundly objected to ending the movie on such a down note and fought hard to include the ending we all know and appreciate.
In June 1998, more than a year after the film wrapped photography, New Line tested a cut of the film edited by Norton independently. With 18 to 24 minutes of footage reinserted into the new version, New Line tried to convince Kaye to support Norton’s editorial changes, but he only got more upset and combative. After voicing his displeasure with the lengthy family conversation, Derek’s anti-immigrant screed, and the flashback of Dennis insulting Derek’s English teacher, New Line compromised and gave Kaye an additional eight weeks to re-cut the film once more.
Despite the studio extending an olive branch, Kaye became more outraged by his creative vision being tinkered with and took a series of head-scratching actions. First, he denigrated Norton and New Line publicly by spending $100,000 on Hollywood press ads that bizarrely quoted Abraham Lincoln and John Lennon. Although he was given the chance to re-edit the film over eight weeks, Kaye balked, claiming he had a radical new vision for the movie and had no idea how long it would take to finish. Part of his plan was to work with Nobel Prize-winning poet Derek Walcott to create new voice-over narration.
Things became so strange that, like right out of a bad bar joke, Kaye brought a priest, a rabbi, and a Buddhist monk to a meeting with New Line producers in the hope of finding some spiritual solution, videotaping the entire process. With such erratic and borderline unstable behavior, the studio had no choice but to release Norton’s edit when Kaye failed to deliver a single frame of new material after the eight weeks allotted for re-editing.
Once Kaye learned New Line planned to release Norton’s 119-minute version, he lobbied to remove his name from the film altogether. He tried to use various aliases, such as Humpty Dumpty, but the Directors Guild of America (DGA) rejected his attempts. As a result, Kaye tried to sue New Line and the DGA for $200 million in a case that was dismissed in 2000. Following the failed lawsuit, Kaye disowned the film outright, despite it garnering widespread critical acclaim for more than a year.
Tony Kaye’s mea culpa
Due to his immature antics, Kaye struggled to find employment after making American History X and didn’t make another feature film until 2006. In 2007, Kaye finally rewatched American History X and offered a mea culpa, stating:
“My ego got in the way. That was entirely my fault. Whenever I can, I take the opportunity to apologize.”
Also in 2007, Kaye directed a documentary about his experience making the movie, which he titled Humpty Dumpty after his presumed pseudonym.
As for the official release of American History X, Norton’s version opened in theaters on October 30, 1998. The film ultimately grossed $23.8 million worldwide, making a small profit on its estimated $20 million budget. Far more lasting is the movie’s near-unanimous critical adoration, with the film holding an 84% Rotten Tomatoes rating and an 8.5 IMDb rating, good enough to rank #42 on the website’s Top 250 Movies of All Time. Norton earned his second Oscar nomination for his truly terrifying yet tender performance, and his first for Best Actor in a Leading Role.
Nearly 30 years after its release, American History X remains so powerful that it is often screened in schools for educational purposes. Look, as conflicted as we are about even talking about neo-Nazism and anti-Semitism, for fear of validating or popularizing their cause, the hard truth is that there has been a stark uptick in such hateful prejudices in the last decade or so, propagated by social media. The power of American History X lies in its sobering and necessary reminder of the work that remains for global society to eradicate such harmful hate in the world.
By dividing the film into color in the present and black and white in the past, the filmmaking technique mirrors this very theme. The flashbacks to Derek’s time as a white supremacist leader show how he views the world in plain black-and-white terms, a thematic visual motif underscoring his racist views. When reformed in the present, the movie is presented in color, indicating how Derek no longer sees the world in black and white and finally sees the real world for what it is: a beautiful melting pot of all colors, shapes, stripes, and sizes. Beyond the movie’s message and powerful performances, that dynamic remains one of the movie’s most lasting legacies.
Adding to the film’s legacy, Kaye announced a follow-up to American History X in 2020 titled African History Y, which he plans to direct with Djimon Hounsou in the lead role. However, after five years in development, little progress on the project has been made public. Even if it does eventually get made, the chances of making a sequel as durable and potent as American History X seem far-fetched.
All in all, that’s essentially what the f*ck happened to American History X. Despite the combative editorial and post-production process, Tony Kaye’s directorial feature debut remains one of the most important movies on its subject ever made. Edward Norton’s indelible performance will live on for the ages, as will the movie’s profound, urgent, and eye-opening anti-racist messaging.
The post WTF Happened to American History X? appeared first on JoBlo.